Has The DNA Database Project Gone Sour?
I recently wrote an article about the proposed expansion of the national DNA database:
http://www.eximium.net/blog/index.php/2008/06/business-advice-luton-6/
This subject and the controversy surrounding it, have featured in the news recently too:
http://www.eximium.net/blog/index.php/2008/09/business-advice-luton-19/
As this news item states, the enquiry by The Human Genetics Commission has recommended that the government removes all the DNA profiles of innocent people and those of criminals who have served their sentence. What I found particularly interesting about this was that this inquiry was funded by the tax payer on the government’s instructions. I thought that the government wanted every UK citizen registered on the database? Isn’t that what Tony Blair said, and was then backed up by Gordon Brown?
I have to ask myself why the government instigated an enquiry at this late stage that was at odds with their vision ‘every UK citizen will be recorded on the DNA database’. Surely this inquiry should have taken place at the outset of the idea, where it could have been properly debated and then acted upon.
Are they telling us that they have only just realised that it may not be a good idea to have innocent peoples’ DNA recorded on the database, so we had to organise an enquiry to cover ourselves? Or perhaps the thoughts at the outset were, ‘Well we know we may have some issues here, but we are going to do it anyway. The overall idea is good and we can sort out the teething problems later. It would be far too much hassle to have a detailed debate or enquiry into the suitability of such an idea, and anyway people might actually object!’
And so what are they going to do with this report?
• Ignore it?
• Act upon it?
• Instigate another enquiry that may have a more favourable outcome?
• Bin the whole idea of a national DNA database?
I think this just goes to emphasise the pitfalls of not carefully planning an approach to the introduction of a new idea, then strictly following the plan, right from inception through to implementation. This becomes even more important when technology is involved.
Ask yourself, does this scenario ever happen in my business, and if so what is it costing me?